NEW YORK — A federal judge has ordered the Trump administration to remove three government-funded advertisements that appeared to promote partisan political messaging, including one highlighting President Donald Trump’s promise that Americans would receive $5,000 payments if Republicans retain control of Congress in the upcoming midterm elections.
U.S. District Judge Jennifer L. Rochon issued the ruling Friday in New York, siding in part with a coalition of organizations that includes the nonpartisan government watchdog Common Cause.
The judge directed federal officials to remove three advertisements titled “$5,000 to Americans,” “Every Democrat Voted Against No Tax on Tips,” and “Cost of Socialism.” However, she declined to order the removal of several other advertisements challenged in the lawsuit.
Under the ruling, the three advertisements must be taken down from official federal government websites and social media accounts, including platforms such as YouTube and Instagram.
Rochon also prohibited the government from proceeding with any planned broadcasts or distribution of the advertisements through authorized third parties, including MAGA Inc., the principal super PAC supporting Trump.
The judge was nominated to the federal bench by former President Joe Biden, a Democrat. Earlier in her legal career, she served as a law clerk to Trump’s late sister, Maryanne Trump Barry, who was a longtime federal appellate judge.
The White House criticized the decision, portraying it as an improper restriction on the administration’s ability to communicate with Americans.
Responding to the ruling, White House spokesperson Lauren Bis said: “This Biden-appointed activist judge issued a lawless order to stop the administration from sharing patriotic videos.”
Friday’s decision came during a hearing in which Rochon considered whether to broaden a temporary restraining order she had issued approximately two weeks earlier.
That earlier order blocked a collection of government advertisements that prominently celebrated Trump and echoed political messages associated with his campaign ahead of the midterm elections.
The plaintiffs had asked the court to remove at least 13 advertisements. Rochon ultimately determined that only three should be prohibited at this stage of the litigation.
In explaining her decision, the judge acknowledged guidance from the Government Accountability Office recognizing that the president’s office may use government resources to explain administration policies, defend those policies and respond to criticism.
She concluded that some restrictions requested by the plaintiffs were “broad and far reaching,” and indicated that the administration was likely to prevail on the legal merits concerning many of the challenged advertisements.
The White House has maintained that the videos are legitimate public service announcements, comparable to communications produced by previous presidential administrations to explain and promote government initiatives.
The organizations challenging the advertisements dispute that characterization. They argue that the videos differ from traditional government public service announcements because they do not primarily provide practical information that would help Americans access or benefit from specific federal programs.
Instead, the plaintiffs contend that taxpayer-funded resources are being used to advance political messages favoring the president and his allies.
Following Friday’s ruling, Rochon emphasized that government officials were expected to comply immediately, noting that the decision had been announced during normal business hours on a Friday afternoon.
A lawyer representing the federal government acknowledged that he could promptly contact the officials responsible for removing the advertisements.
“Everyone is here. Everyone can hear my order. No one is at the theater,” Rochon remarked.
Her comment referenced explanations previously offered by government attorneys when officials failed to immediately comply with an earlier court order issued during a weekend.
The judge also explained that allowing the disputed advertisements to remain publicly available while the lawsuit proceeded could cause irreparable harm to the organizations challenging them.
Nevertheless, Rochon stressed that her decision was temporary. She could ultimately reinstate the advertisements or extend the restrictions to additional government-produced videos after reviewing further evidence in the coming weeks.
“This court can neither postpone an election nor turn back the clock,” Rochon said.
She determined that the plaintiffs had demonstrated a likelihood of succeeding on their legal claims concerning the three advertisements and could suffer harm if the court did not intervene before the election.
Attorneys representing the coalition welcomed the ruling as an important step toward preventing federal resources from being used for partisan political advertising.
“This temporary restraining order will stop the administration’s wanton disregard for the law while the court hears the full case,” said Bradley Girard, an attorney with Democracy Forward.
“Congress has made clear that partisan ads cannot be funded with taxpayer dollars, and we are proud to work with this coalition to earn today’s result.”
In written arguments submitted to the court, lawyers for the coalition maintained that Congress had not authorized the president’s office to spend public funds “to run a PR shop to help the President’s allies and attack his perceived ideological opponents.”
The Justice Department, however, defended the administration’s communications strategy.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Jeffrey Oestericher argued in court filings that White House employees were acting within their authority by producing advertisements designed to “inform the public about his policies and to rebut attacks on those policies and his Administration.”
The dispute will continue as the court considers whether the challenged advertisements constitute permissible government communications or unlawfully taxpayer-funded political advocacy.